View Source

{info}
This is the central page for the OOI CI Release 3 Life Cycle Objectives (LCO) Review.

*Quick Info: Meeting start 8:30 am at Qualcomm Room, Jacobs Hall, UCSD*
{info}
{tip}This is the CI's R3 LCO Review page, not the *[EPE's R3 LCO Review page|EPEDev:Release 3 Life Cycle Objectives Review]*.{tip}
{section}
{column}
{color:blue}On this Page{color}
{toc}
{column}
{column}
{color:blue}Quick Links{color}
* [LCO Agenda|R3 LCO Agenda]
* [Index to Presentations|Index to R3 LCO Presentations]
* [Etherpad for community notes|http://etherpad.oceanobservatories.org/r3lco]
* [Etherpad for the *board only*|http://etherpad.oceanobservatories.org/r3lcoboard]
* [LCO Artifacts|syseng:R3 LCO Materials]
* [LCO Logistics|R3 LCO Meeting Logistics]
{column}
{section}

h2. Introduction to Cyberinfrastructure Release 3 LCO Review

This is the central page for the Release 3 LCO Review, scheduled January 8 to 9, 2013 at UC San Diego.

The LCO ([Life Cycle Objectives Review]) is the first milestone in the spiral development process, ending the [Inception spiral phase|Inception Phase].

The LCO review brings together a board of representative reviewers to assess the adequate achievement of the LCO milestone, a prerequisite to moving the project into [Elaboration spiral phase|Elaboration Phase]. The scope of this review is the LCO for the third of four releases of the OOI CI.

This page and all materials will remain as a reference throughout the program.

h2. Meeting Objectives

For all such reviews, through collaborative constructive review and critique of architectural plans and development efforts, determine whether activities associated with the previous phase are adequately complete, and that the subsystems under review are sufficiently advanced to progress to the next phase (or exit the release). All of the milestone reviews, along with entry criteria (deliverables for the review) and success (exit) criteria, are described in 2110-00006 System Life Cycle Plan, a document that is available on Alfresco.

h3. LCO Meeting Objectives

In particular, determine answers to the following:

* Are the use cases understood, and do they provide a complete description of the release scope?
* Are the candidate requirements understood, and do they cover the critical use cases?
* Are the critical risks identified, and have they been mitigated through exploratory prototypes?
* Are the candidate architectures viable as demonstrated through analysis and prototyping?
* Is the Elaboration Execution Plan credible?

h2. Meeting Materials

* [Agenda|R3 LCO Agenda]
* [Index to Presentations|Index to R3 LCO Presentations] (including links to slide presentations)
* Review Materials (Baseline Artifact Set)
** [LCO Release 3 Baseline Artifacts|syseng:R3 LCO Materials]

h3. Collaboration Pages

During the meeting, collaborative notes will be taken on this Etherpad page (you may visit and help).
* [Real-Time Etherpad Meeting Notes|http://etherpad.oceanobservatories.org/r3lco]

After the meeting, these pages will contain the material from the Etherpads.
* [Archival Meeting Notes|R3 LCO Meeting Notes]

h3. Review Outcome

Subsequent to the review, the review panel compiles a review report addressing findings, open issues and a recommendation about proceeding into the elaboration phase of CI development. This publicly relevant parts of the report, and any OOI CI team responses, are available here.

* R3 LCO Review Panel Presentation (presentation by review panel at end of review)
* R3 LCO Review Panel Report (includes notes of in-meeting Q&A, and CI response)




h2. General Information

*January 8-9, 2013*


[syseng:R3 LCO Meeting Logistics]


h3. [syseng:R3 LCO WebEx Information]


h4. Review Board

* Sue Banahan - COL (Chair)
* Mark Fornwall - USGS
* Douglas Luther - RSN
* Steve Gaul - CGSN
* Ed Chapman - COL
* Jonathan Fram - EA
* Arthur Miller - SIO
* Andrea McCurdy - COL

h4. Attendee List

|| Last Name || First Name || Institution ||
| Altintas \\ | Ilkay \\ | San Diego Supercomputer Center, UCSD |
| Ampe | Tim \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD \\ |
| Arrott \\ | Matthew \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Balasuriya \\ | Arjuna \\ | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Banahan\* \\ | Sue \\ | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
| Bauer \\ | Rita \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD \\ |
| Bergen \\ | Bill \\ | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
| Chapman\* \\ | Ed \\ | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
| Chao | Yi | Remote Sensing Solutions |
| Chave \\ | Alan \\ | Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution \\ |
| Cowart \\ | Charles \\ | San Diego Supercomputer Center, UCSD |
| Cressey \\ | Rod \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Dean \\ | Paul \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Edgington \\ | Duane \\ | Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute |
| Fornwall\* \\ | Mark \\ | United States Geological Survey |
| Fram\* \\ | Jonathan \\ | Oregon State University |
| French \\ | Bill \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Gaul\* \\ | Steve \\ | Raytheon |
| Graybeal \\ | John \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Henrie \\ | Stephen \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Hunter \\ | Edward \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Jul \\ | Susanne \\ | Amaryllis Consulting \\ |
| Keahey \\ | Kate \\ | Argonne National Laboratory \\ |
| Kilb \\ | Debi \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Luther\* \\ | Douglas \\ | University of Hawaii |
| Manning \\ | Maurice \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| McCurdy | Andrea | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
| McGovern \\ | Jean \\ | National Science Foundation |
| McPhail \\ | Tim \\ | Science Applications International Corporation \\ |
| Meisinger \\ | Michael \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Miller, Dr.\* \\ | Arthur \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Orcutt \\ | John \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| O'Reilly \\ | Tom \\ | Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute |
| Pritchett \\ | Bill \\ | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
| Schilining \\ | Brian \\ | Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute |
| Schmidt \\ | Henrik \\ | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Stocks \\ | Karen \\ | San Diego Supercomputer Center, UCSD |
| Thomas \\ | Julie \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Tucker \\ | Kelly \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Vernon \\ | Frank \\ | Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UCSD |
| Yaari \\ | Alon \\ | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Yoshida \\ | Nobuko \\ | Imperial College London |
| Zernick \\ | Mike \\ | Consortium for Ocean Leadership |
* Review Board Member

h3. Meeting Location

h4. UCSD, Jacobs Hall (EBU-1), School of Engineering: [Qualcomm Conference Center|^Directions to JSOE.pdf]

h2. Contacts

If you have any questions or concerns about the meeting, please contact Paul Dean (pdean@ucsd.edu) or Rita Bauer (rmbauer@ucsd.edu) at UCSD.

*Paul Dean*
Assistant Program Coordinator
Scripps Institution of Oceanography
9500 Gilman Drive.
La Jolla, CA 92093-0436
Telephone:  858-822-0878 / Fax:  858-822-4633 

*Rita Bauer*
Special Projects Coordinator
Scripps Institution of Oceanography
Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics
9500 Gilman Drive
La Jolla, CA 92093-0225
Telephone: 858-822-2946 / Fax: 858-822-337